Choosing between the Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus comes down to how much control you want over your coffee. Both brew fast with rich flavor, but the Plus adds temperature settings, user profiles, and a larger tank. From my own use, the Supreme felt simple and reliable, while the Plus gave me more freedom to fine-tune every cup. If you’re deciding which one fits your routine, here’s an honest breakdown to help you pick with confidence.
For me, mornings often mean rushing out the door. With the Supreme, I can brew a hot 8-oz cup in under two minutes without fuss. I’ve also used the Brew Over Ice setting in summer to make iced coffee, and it’s surprisingly refreshing. Another handy feature is the 66-oz water reservoir, which I keep on the side to save counter space. It lasts me through several cups before refilling.
Compared to the Keurig Supreme Plus, this model is a little simpler, but for someone who values speed and consistent coffee, the Supreme covers all the basics very well.
What I Like
- Flavor is noticeably better: The MultiStream Technology extracts more flavor than the older Keurig I had. Coffee feels fuller, not watery.
- Flexible water tank placement: I liked that I could slide the 66-oz reservoir to the back or the side. This made it fit better in my kitchen.
- Strong Brew and Brew Over Ice: I use Strong Brew on busy mornings when I want a bold cup. Brew Over Ice is perfect for hot summer days here in the U.S., where iced coffee is a go-to.
- Travel mug friendly: My tall stainless steel mug fits right under it without me needing to brew into a smaller cup first.
What Could Be Better
- No temperature control: Unlike the Supreme Plus, this one doesn’t let me adjust the temperature. Some pods taste better at slightly lower heat.
- Plastic feel: The build feels more plastic than premium. It’s sturdy enough but doesn’t have the “solid” feel of higher-end machines.
- Pods only: While K-Cups are everywhere in the U.S. (grocery stores, even gas stations), it would be nice if Keurig included a reusable filter by default.
Recommendation
I’d recommend the Keurig Supreme to anyone who wants fast, flavorful coffee without overcomplicating things. It’s especially great for busy households, small apartments, or offices where convenience matters. If you love iced coffee or need a machine that fits a travel mug, this one works well.
But if you’re the kind of coffee drinker who wants extra control like changing brew temperature or saving user profiles,
you may want to look at the Keurig Supreme Plus instead.
For U.S. buyers, the availability of K-Cups is a big win. Whether you prefer Starbucks, Dunkin’, or smaller brands, you can find pods easily in local stores or order online. Just keep in mind that costs can add up if you drink several cups daily.
Is Keurig Supreme Plus Good?
Yes, the Keurig Supreme Plus is a good choice if you want more control over your coffee. I’ve used it for weeks, and what stood out most was the level of customization. With five brew strengths and six temperature settings, I could make a light breakfast coffee or a bold evening cup, all from the same machine.
One morning, I brewed an iced coffee using the Over Ice button, and the flavor held up well without getting watery. On busy days, the programmable user profiles became a lifesaver. I set mine for strong 10-oz brews, while my partner saved a lighter 8-oz setting. With one button, we each had our coffee the way we like it.
The 78-oz reservoir was also handy. In my house, we go through several cups a day, and this meant fewer trips to refill. Compared to the standard Supreme, the Plus feels built for households or offices where coffee runs nonstop.
What I Like
- Deep customization: I loved being able to pick between different strengths and temperatures. It let me match the brew to the K-Cup flavor I was using.
- User profiles: Setting up three profiles meant no more re-adjusting every morning. It saved me time and avoided arguments about “who changed the settings.”
- Larger water tank: The 78-oz tank was big enough for several brews, perfect when friends visited. In U.S. households where coffee is often shared, this makes a real difference.
- Over Ice setting: Iced coffee came out smooth and not diluted. For hot summers, this was one of my favorite features.
What Could Be Better
- Higher price tag: The Supreme Plus costs more than the standard Supreme. The extra features are worth it if you’ll use them, but it may feel expensive for casual drinkers.
- Takes up more space: The larger reservoir is great for capacity, but it does make the machine bulkier on smaller counters.
- Pods can add up: While K-Cups are easy to find across the U.S., they do cost more per cup than ground coffee. I wish Keurig included the reusable filter by default.
I’d recommend the Keurig Supreme Plus to coffee drinkers who value control and drink multiple cups a day. It’s perfect for families, offices, or anyone who shares a machine since you can save different brew profiles. If you enjoy both hot and iced coffee, it checks both boxes.
If you just want fast, straightforward brewing, the regular Keurig Supreme might be enough. But if you like tweaking strength, temperature, or want fewer refills thanks to the bigger tank, the Plus is the better long-term investment.
For U.S. buyers, one perk is the huge variety of K-Cups available. Whether it’s Starbucks, Dunkin’, or smaller craft brands, you’ll find them in local grocery stores or online. That makes it easy to experiment with flavors while using the customization features of the Supreme Plus.
Detailed Comparison: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
I’ve used both the Keurig Supreme and the Keurig Supreme Plus. At first glance, they look similar, but after brewing many cups, I found clear differences. Here’s how they stack up side by side in real use.
Brewing Speed: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
Both machines are fast. The Keurig Supreme brews a cup in under two minutes, while the Supreme Plus is just as quick. I didn’t notice a big time gap, but the Plus seemed a little smoother with back-to-back brews.
In my experience, mornings with guests felt easier with the Plus since I could make cup after cup without delays. But for single-use mornings, the regular Supreme worked fine.
- Keurig Supreme: 9/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9.5/10
Coffee Temperature: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
Here’s where the difference shows. The Supreme gives a consistent hot cup, but the Supreme Plus lets me pick from six temperature settings. That extra control helped when brewing lighter roasts that taste better at slightly lower temps.
I enjoyed this feature on the Plus, especially when making iced coffee. Lower heat meant less ice melt and a better final drink.
- Keurig Supreme: 8.5/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9.5/10
Water Tank Capacity: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
The Keurig Supreme has a 66-oz reservoir, while the Plus upgrades to 78 oz. That difference matters when you’re brewing multiple cups daily.
When I had family visiting, the Supreme Plus cut down on refills, which made mornings stress-free. With the regular Supreme, I had to refill more often, which wasn’t a dealbreaker, but less convenient.
- Keurig Supreme: 8/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9.5/10
Filter Quality: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
Both use the same style of filter with MultiStream Technology. The Plus doesn’t upgrade the filter itself, but the stronger customization options made the coffee feel more tailored.
In daily use, the difference wasn’t huge, but the Plus gave me a slight edge in taste when paired with stronger settings.
- Keurig Supreme: 8.5/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9/10
Brew Quality: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
Both models use MultiStream Technology, which soaks grounds better than older Keurigs. The Supreme delivers a noticeable upgrade in taste, while the Supreme Plus lets you fine-tune flavor with strength and temperature options.
Personally, I found the Plus more satisfying for bold roasts. The regular Supreme was great for quick daily brews, but it lacked the “craft” feel that the Plus offered.
- Keurig Supreme: 8.5/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9.5/10
Performance: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
The Supreme works well for simple, everyday use. The Supreme Plus adds advanced features that make it feel more premium. Both perform reliably, but the Plus stands out for flexibility.
From my use, the Plus handled busy mornings better and felt like the machine I could rely on long term.
- Keurig Supreme: 8.5/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9.5/10
Ease of Use: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
The Keurig Supreme is simple — pick a size, brew, done. The Plus adds more buttons, but I didn’t find it confusing. In fact, the user profiles on the Plus saved me time since I didn’t need to reset options each morning.
For friends or guests, the regular Supreme was easier to explain. For personal use, the Plus felt smarter.
- Keurig Supreme: 9/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9/10
Value for Money: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
The Supreme is cheaper, and for someone who just wants fast coffee, it’s enough. The Plus costs more, but if you’ll use the customization features, it’s worth it.
When I compared price vs features, the Plus felt like a better long-term deal for a household. But for solo use, the regular Supreme gave me plenty of value.
- Keurig Supreme: 8.5/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9/10
Overall: Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
After weeks of use, I’d say the Keurig Supreme is a solid, no-frills coffee maker that makes good use of MultiStream Technology. The Supreme Plus is for coffee lovers who want more control, fewer refills, and a richer experience.
My honest take: I enjoyed both, but I reached for the Plus more often because of its customization and bigger reservoir.
- Keurig Supreme: 8.5/10
- Keurig Supreme Plus: 9.5/10
FAQs for Keurig Supreme vs Supreme Plus
What is the main difference between Keurig Supreme and Supreme Plus?
The Keurig Supreme is simple with strong brew and iced coffee options, while the Supreme Plus adds more strength, temperature, and profile settings.
Does the Keurig Supreme Plus make hotter coffee than the Supreme?
Yes, the Supreme Plus offers six temperature settings for hotter or milder coffee. The regular Supreme has a fixed temperature option only.
Which has a bigger water tank: Keurig Supreme or Supreme Plus?
The Keurig Supreme holds 66 oz, while the Supreme Plus holds 78 oz. The larger tank means fewer refills, making it better for families or heavy coffee drinkers.
Is the Keurig Supreme Plus worth the extra cost?
If you like customization, stronger coffee, and less refilling, the Plus is worth it. For basic brewing needs, the regular Keurig Supreme is more budget-friendly.
Which is better for iced coffee: Keurig Supreme or Supreme Plus?
Both have a Brew Over Ice button. The Supreme Plus offers more control with temperature, making iced coffee taste smoother and less watered down.
0 Comments